It's "an historic mistake" that will "make the world more dangerous" - the result of cosmetic concessions - and the consequences "threaten Israel". And: "We will not allow Iran to obtain military capability."
Benjamin Netanyahu's take on the interim deal to limit Iran's nuclear programme could not be more out of tune with how the US President plays it.
Barack Obama said the agreement "opened up a new path toward a world that is more secure".
That the two men don't get along could be a diplomatic understatement. But why the huge gulf over what is an historic turning point in Iran's relations with the outside world?
It's partly caused by policy, and partly by personality. The deal with Iran is less of a turning point - more a junction.
The Israelis contend the world's superpowers and global diplomats have been suckered and that Iran has taken a devious route. The Saudis probably agree - though may not say so out loud.
Israel sees an Iranian nuclear weapon as an existential threat - the Saudis fear Iran's Shi'a agenda which has already established an arc of influence from Iraq to Syria.
The US, Europe, Russia and China see Iran has opted for a different road - one that will lead it back into the community of nations - and one that will have checkpoints manned by the International Atomic Energy Authority.
It will only be clear which direction Iran has really chosen over the next six months. These are rational differences of difference of policy.
Mr Obama says the deal opens a path to 'a world that is more secure' An objective analysis of the interim deal, which is intended to lead to a permanent end to Iran's nuclear weapons programme in return for the end of crippling sanctions in six months, it is pretty good.
Enrichment of uranium will be halted at 5% (well below the weapons threshold purity of 90%). Iran's stockpile of 30% enriched uranium will be neutralised.
Tehran's capacity to re-start its nuclear weapons programme is also being rolled back. Centrifuges for enrichment will be put out of action and no new ones built. The plutonium reactor at Arak will, effectively, be mothballed before its completion.
IAEA inspectors will be given regular and unrestrained access to the nuclear sites and even access to CCTV cameras to try to ensure that Iran isn't backsliding.
In return, Iran gets access to airplane parts, and partial lifting of sanctions on the oil and gold industry worth $1.5bn a year.
It will also get, in instalments, revenues from $4.2bn worth of oil revenues - and $400m will be allowed to be sent to Iranian students and other educational projects abroad.
Iran will still be losing out on $4bn a month in oil sales because of caps on its exports, and $100bn of its foreign exchange will remain in frozen bank accounts.
The nuclear talks in Geneva These simply are not the "cosmetic concessions" that the Israeli Prime Minister claims.
It is true that many western intelligence agencies share the Israeli fear that the international community may be falling into an Iranian trap.
"They are world class liars," one senior spook said.
But there is no need to say so - yet.
"All Bibi (Benjamin Netanyahu) needs to do is say he reserves judgement on the interim agreement and hope that diplomacy will work - give the whole thing its six months and then if Iran is indeed cheating, Israel will have global support for more drastic action," said one western diplomat.
He risks being 'tuned out' by the international community - even if what he may say, in the end, is proved incorrect, the diplomat added.
Often belligerent Israel, led by Mr Netanyahu's personal style, is now being seen as petulant.
Behaviour that is trying the patience of its father figure - the USA.
Anda sedang membaca artikel tentang
Israel Says Nuclear Deal Is 'Historic Mistake'
Dengan url
http://badutjayus.blogspot.com/2013/11/israel-says-nuclear-deal-is-historic.html
Anda boleh menyebar luaskannya atau mengcopy paste-nya
Israel Says Nuclear Deal Is 'Historic Mistake'
namun jangan lupa untuk meletakkan link
Israel Says Nuclear Deal Is 'Historic Mistake'
sebagai sumbernya
0 komentar:
Posting Komentar